BSD Chapter 113 Historical Analysis

BSD Chapter 113 Historical Analysis

Basically, I can put my History and Religious Studies Degree and put that shit to use and do some good for society

Essentially, I think chapter 113 left us clues for hinting at the bigger themes of Bungo Stray Dogs and possibly some insight into Fyodor's motivation for being caught by Bram. This might get long so buckle up bitch.

OH AND I THINK I FIGURED OUT THE EXACT YEAR THE DUNGEON MEMORY TAKES PLACE

Okay, so the first thing to understand is the contemporary events mentioned in Chapter 113. The guards and Bram mention King Matthias, the Sultan, and the Holy Crusaders.

The Crusades, for those of you who don't know, are a series of so-called Holy Wars whose main objective was the "reclamation" of the Holy Land. However, not all crusades had this objective. There were several crusades within Europe itself. These wars, like the Cathar Crusade, were aimed at driving out paganism or "heretical” sects of Christianity. While the main Crusades happened centuries before the Dungeon scene took place (the first official Crusade happening in 1095) there existed later Crusades that often sought to limit the authority and scope of the Ottoman Empire. Which is also mentioned in the chapter with "Sultan"

Now the Sultan mentioned is Mehemed II, often referred to as the Father of Conquest. He was in power when King Matthias (Matthias was the King of Hungary and Croatia) ruled and often fought to expand Ottoman territory into the lands Matthias ruled.

Now, you know who else was a contemporary ruler? Our boy Vlad Dracul, the inspiration behind Bram Stoker's Dracula.

Now, Vlad Dracul was the ruler of Wallachia, which is basically Romania today. Now it is my belief that Bram Stoker. like a lot of characters in BSD, is inspired by the tale of Dracula and not the actual Bram Stoker. But, I think instead of using the character of Dracula, Asagiri is using Vlad Dracul (also known as Vlad Tepes) as Bram's inspiration. This is for two reasons. 1. The castle depicted in the manga is the same castle Vlad ruled from 2. Bram states that he wants Fyodor skewed like a little shrimpy on the grill. Vlad Dracul got his bloodthirsty reputation by impaling his enemies and leaving their heads on pikes outside his castle for several months at a time. In fact, I forget the exact quote, but a visitor of the castle during Vlad's reign said you could smell the decaying rotten flesh for miles before arriving at the castle. This is why Bram Stoker wrote Dracula based on Vlad Dracul.

Now as for the specific year the memory takes place, I personally believe it takes place in the year 1462, either summer or early fall. Once again this is based on the textual evidence given in the manga... The guards are clearly nervous about the sultan, who we have established is Mehemed II. This guy is responsible for the downfall of the Byzantine (or Eastern Roman Empire) and founded the Ottoman Empire. He also has beef with Vlad since Vlad brutally killed Ottoman envoys sent to Wallachia in an attempt to make Wallachia a vassal state for the Ottomans. Moreover, 1462 was the year that Vlad was imprisoned by King Matthias till his release in 1475. During this time Wallachia was essentially conquered. Vlad died between 1476 and 1477 (the sources don't have a specific date).

Now historically speaking there is reason as to why King Matthias imprisoned Vlad. A letter, which a lot of scholars think was made up, allegedly claimed Vlad pledged his allegiance to the Ottomans to help them conquer Hungary and Croatia. Now, strictly speaking for the events of the manga, having Bram imprisoned and/or taken out of power sounds like something Fyodor would do. So it makes sense that in the manga he would have something to do with Bram being imprisoned. If Bram is imprisoned that is to say since we still don't have clear motives for that.

It should also be noted that Fyodor warns Bram that the "Gods of Warfare come from the West”. historically speaking it was the Ottoman Empire that caused Wallachia problems and not the Holy Roman Empire aka the Romans mentioned in the chapter. The only reason I can think of the guards and Bram suspecting "holy crusaders" and "Romans" is because of their differing religious beliefs. Now Wallachia followed Orthodox Christianity while Romans obviously followed Roman Catholic traditions. Protestantism wasn't a thing yet, but these two groups were already tense and there have been several major conflicts (like the Crusades I mentioned earlier) and schisms within the church.

So, this is the only thing I could think of, but I'm not sure of what Fyodor's play is at here. Maybe he's an immortal being wanting to rid the world of abilities and having Bram Stoker in chaos would help in advance that goal. Maybe he can take people's life forces away like I've seen a lot of people suggest. I don't know. And the whole "come from the West" quote is the one thing throwing me off. Overall, I would love to know if Asagiri used any sources from the period to influence this memory scene, and if so...I wanna know which one's bestie!!

Please let me know what you think! If I just rambled or if my sleep-deprived thoughts and research make any semblance of sense. I would also love to know any fun theories and/or facts you have about this chapter or BSD in general. Also, would pictures be helpful?

More Posts from Adaintern and Others

1 year ago

Ooo so there’s a theory I saw from @bluemooniegif where the people shown are just the one’s Fukuzawa’s ability applies too. Because if you think about it, wouldn’t he also think of Naomi and Haruno as part of the agency too? And since they don’t have abilities and Dazai would nullify All Men Are Created Equal, they aren’t shown. As for Ranpo, they said that it’s probably something to with that Ranpo thinks/thought he had an ability and Fukuzawa kinda helped him cultivate that idea and taught him how to control “his ability” with the glasses he gave him in untold origins. And I thought this made so much sense because Naomi and Haruno are Fukuzawa’s secretaries and I don’t think he would forget about them or not consider them vital to the agency.

Maybe I didn't notice in the anime but why is Dazai not there when Fukuzawa's thinking of the agency?????

Maybe I Didn't Notice In The Anime But Why Is Dazai Not There When Fukuzawa's Thinking Of The Agency?????

Tags
1 year ago

Do you ever start thinking about the fact that Dazai literally made tiny snowmen based on his favourite people? The ones he secretly keeps in his heart?

Do You Ever Start Thinking About The Fact That Dazai Literally Made Tiny Snowmen Based On His Favourite

Said people being:

- ANGO

- ODASAKU

- ATSUSHI

- CHUUYA

Do You Ever Start Thinking About The Fact That Dazai Literally Made Tiny Snowmen Based On His Favourite
Do You Ever Start Thinking About The Fact That Dazai Literally Made Tiny Snowmen Based On His Favourite
Do You Ever Start Thinking About The Fact That Dazai Literally Made Tiny Snowmen Based On His Favourite
Do You Ever Start Thinking About The Fact That Dazai Literally Made Tiny Snowmen Based On His Favourite

AND I BELIEVE IT'S BEAUTIFUL


Tags
1 year ago

So…I was right. Bastard knew. And he probably felt good saying it too since he sees himself as the worlds savior

Fyodor's Last Words in Bungou Stray Dogs

Hello! I know I've been saying I was gonna do this for a long time, and I really did try to find my notes quickly, but I'm here now. This post is meant as a Religious Studies Analysis. As such I would like to state that I was a dual major in Religious Studies and History to qualify myself for this discussion.

I am also going to be writing this post for accessibility, that is to say I am going to assume the reader has little to no knowledge about the New Testament so I will be explaining or giving context to a lot of things, even things that may seem obvious.

What Were Fyodor's Words?

Fyodor's Last Words In Bungou Stray Dogs

Eli, Eli, Lema Sabachtani which as I'm sure you know is the Arameic version of Christ's cry to God as he was on the Cross in the Book of Matthew. The Book of Matthew is one of the four gospels in the New Testament. The Gospels (which translates to Good News) tell the life story of Jesus.

In the King James Version of the Bible these words are said, "And about the ninth hour Jesus cried with a loud voice, saying, Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani? that is to say, My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? (Matthew 27:46)

A disclaimer, I am using the King James Version of the Bible for its importance to the English Language. If you want to see Matthew 27:46 translated differently please check Bible Gateway.

The Significance of Matthew 27:46

Let's talk about the context of Matthew 27:46. Now, this line comes during the Crucifixion of Jesus. This was the ninth hour of Jesus being on the cross, or around 3 in the afternoon, and is said following a period of darkness from noon to three.

Now many scholars and theologians have tried to understand why Jesus would have said God had forsaken him, and this is the same for Fyodor too.

However, I would like to talk about Matthew 27:46 in the context of prophecy. Now, for many Christian scholars the Hebrew Bible (Old Testament) contain several prophecies which Jesus later fulfills. In Psalms 22:1 "Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani?" is said once again. Therefore, a popular interpretation of Matthew 27:46 is that Jesus is emphasizing how his death and eventual resurrection were all proclaimed long ago and fated to happen.

In short: the quote illustrates the prophetic nature of Jesus and how he is the Messiah.

And How Does Fyodor Connect?

Well, I believe that Fyodor's last words were a warning. A warning to Dazai that Fyodor knew he would "die" and come back, just as Jesus did when he said it on the cross. Maybe he planned this all out or views his life as some sort of prophecy to eliminate all ability users.

If we take the quote and apply the Psalms connection to it, it becomes evident that the "sacrifice" Fyodor took was fated to happen and he knew it. He knew he was going to come back, he possibly knew this was going to happen.

Moreover, this quote may also have something to do with his resurrection. Later in Matthew (Matthew 27:50-53), Jesus calls out and an earthquake happens, "and the graves were opened; and many bodies of the saints which slept arose." (Matthew 27:52). Right after Jesus calls out to God, the saints rise from the dead and go to heaven. The quote is intimately tied with resurrection, and I don't think that's a coincidence that Fyodor said it and then comes back. I think Asagiri took this into consideration too.

Most people would think that "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" would be a plea of a man caught in a trap with no way out. But, this interpretation does not make sense with Fyodor or his "death". Therefore, understanding Matthew 27:46 has both a line connected with the resurrection of saints and prophecy is crucial to understanding why Fyodor said it during the helicopter crash. He knew he was coming back. I think it was a warning and to illustrate how "ordained by God" his mission is. There's probably more context to add, but it's late and I am sleepy now.

I know this all kinda confirms what we already know, but I think it really illustrates the depth of Fyodor's planning and that he might have known how Mersault was going to go the whole time. Which is terrifying if you think about it.

As always feel free to add things, ask questions, etc. If you disagree just keep it civil. There's probably some things manga wise I didn't add so if you have things to add please do.

Fyodor's Last Words In Bungou Stray Dogs

Tags
1 year ago

Thinking about how the appearance of Fyodor comes with the implication that something bad has happened to Dazai.

Atsushi's blood runs cold. His eyes wide and darting around. He activates the tigers senses and just like so many times lately he can't sense Dazai at all.

But that doesn't mean anything, he reminds himself. It doesn't mean... It can't.

Ranpo looks down, determined and not willing to even entertain the possibility. His glasses burn a hole in his pocket but he won't reach for them.

He can't.

Kunikida who's recovering from having his heart stopped is dragging himself to his feet. There's anger in his bones and a fear he won't admit too as he demands "Where is he?!

Kunikida will drag him back himself if he has too. Just like he always does.

Fukuzawa, heart pounding his ears holds onto faith in steady hands. He won't jump to conclusions, he won't cloud his mind. Because Dazai earned his trust a long time ago.

He will have a home to return to, and that Fukuzawa swears on.


Tags
1 year ago

I’ll need some fanfic of this for real cause this is too damn cute

"The first round's on you."

— Kunikida to Dazai in the very first episode

Guys, they drink together. Like, socially, with other members of the ADA. They have actual conversations about not-work stuff.


Tags
1 year ago

Real

Let's all just ignore the pain and just think about how pretty Dazai looked in this chapter instead <3


Tags
1 year ago
ASAGIRI EXPLAIN

ASAGIRI EXPLAIN


Tags
1 year ago

Doodles

Found some funny thumbnails on YT, so I decided to style it up a bit XDD

Doodles
Doodles
Doodles
Doodles
Doodles

Tags
1 year ago

you can click on this button once daily to help palestine and support other causes in the middle east for free. it takes literally 5 seconds and could help save lives so please take the time to click and share this link.


Tags
6 months ago
Dazai And Momiji

Dazai and momiji

(from a mayoi card) ⬇️

quality is bad... I know I should scan everything instead of photos but it broke. one day I will 🥹

Dazai And Momiji
Dazai And Momiji
Dazai And Momiji

Tags
Loading...
End of content
No more pages to load
  • soda-sunrays
    soda-sunrays reblogged this · 2 days ago
  • soda-sunrays
    soda-sunrays liked this · 2 days ago
  • whatisrealnowadays
    whatisrealnowadays liked this · 7 months ago
  • coffinjest
    coffinjest liked this · 8 months ago
  • cherrry6wine
    cherrry6wine liked this · 9 months ago
  • xbookmanx
    xbookmanx liked this · 11 months ago
  • theinsomniacindian
    theinsomniacindian liked this · 1 year ago
  • d-a-1997
    d-a-1997 liked this · 1 year ago
  • chiclete-com-pipoca
    chiclete-com-pipoca liked this · 1 year ago
  • hysm1na3
    hysm1na3 liked this · 1 year ago
  • cloud-of-mist
    cloud-of-mist liked this · 1 year ago
  • obsidianstrawberrymilk
    obsidianstrawberrymilk reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • dazaiesques
    dazaiesques liked this · 1 year ago
  • sword-lily4951
    sword-lily4951 reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • sword-lily4951
    sword-lily4951 liked this · 1 year ago
  • doctor--malpractice
    doctor--malpractice liked this · 1 year ago
  • idkgothic
    idkgothic liked this · 1 year ago
  • itzm1yah
    itzm1yah liked this · 1 year ago
  • 149panda149
    149panda149 liked this · 1 year ago
  • cloverhelium
    cloverhelium liked this · 1 year ago
  • jollyzonkwombatfestival
    jollyzonkwombatfestival liked this · 1 year ago
  • morilovern1
    morilovern1 liked this · 1 year ago
  • declamationark
    declamationark reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • declamationark
    declamationark liked this · 1 year ago
  • booqoop
    booqoop liked this · 1 year ago
  • thecrazyone0
    thecrazyone0 liked this · 1 year ago
  • elizaelisabethelisa
    elizaelisabethelisa reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • elizaelisabethelisa
    elizaelisabethelisa liked this · 1 year ago
  • lurkinginthefridge
    lurkinginthefridge liked this · 1 year ago
  • an-endless-matryoshka-of-dazais
    an-endless-matryoshka-of-dazais liked this · 1 year ago
  • annemariearcher
    annemariearcher liked this · 1 year ago
  • pebblul
    pebblul liked this · 1 year ago
  • minehunii
    minehunii liked this · 1 year ago
  • sa1ty-1icorice
    sa1ty-1icorice liked this · 1 year ago
  • fvedyetor
    fvedyetor liked this · 1 year ago
  • haltijatar
    haltijatar liked this · 1 year ago
  • okultrawarrior
    okultrawarrior liked this · 1 year ago
  • nonononononononononononon
    nonononononononononononon reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • nonononononononononononon
    nonononononononononononon liked this · 1 year ago
  • luzavart
    luzavart liked this · 1 year ago
  • leirye
    leirye liked this · 1 year ago
  • psychicbakerycloudpaper
    psychicbakerycloudpaper liked this · 1 year ago
  • honeecrusad3r
    honeecrusad3r liked this · 1 year ago
  • irunoncaffeine
    irunoncaffeine liked this · 1 year ago
  • marlyen-rose69
    marlyen-rose69 liked this · 1 year ago
  • flyolai-brainrot
    flyolai-brainrot reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • flyolai-brainrot
    flyolai-brainrot liked this · 1 year ago
  • akaspiriti
    akaspiriti liked this · 1 year ago
  • ay-masakali
    ay-masakali reblogged this · 1 year ago
adaintern - I am normal about Dazai
I am normal about Dazai

Jamie, ENTP, 25, sometimes I have thoughts

82 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags