I Didn’t Mean To Start A Debate, But Since We’re At It . . . .

I didn’t mean to start a debate, but since we’re at it . . . .

Starlight was a broken and lonely pony. She didn’t want to be alone, and she hurt people in an obscene way to achieve that. Obviously, the things that she did was terrifying and I also think her redemption was rushed (discords redemption arc is the only one I truly adore in FiM) but after her initial redemption she struggles to fit in and cope with how terrible she was to ponies. We see how her horrible actions hurt her later in life as well. Chancellor Neigh Say literally flipped like a switch (I have only finished season 8, so if his redemption is more fleshed out in season 9 I may backtrack this opinion, but don’t give me any spoilers). He went from extremely racist and hell bent on destroying Twilight and everything she has built, and one incident toppled him on his head and turned him into a good guy without any repercussions for the things he did and said and how he treated literal CHILDREN. Do y’all realize that? He chained up innocent CHILDREN. He doesn’t deserve a redemption arc because his only justification for his horrible treatment of non-pony creatures was simply that. Because they were non-ponies.

If a character has such violently hateful opinions of other species and his entire personality was written around him being a pony supremicist, then no, I don’t think he deserves a redemption arc. No one changes that easily, especially on that kind of opinion. If it was taken more slowly and dug a little deeper into his rooted dislike for other creatures, I could give him a chance. But not with the knowledge I currently have of him. But again, I’ve only seen up until season 8, so any actions he may take in season 9 could very well change this opinion.

I just finished season 8 of FiM.

Chancellor Neigh Say shouldn't have been redeemed.

Tags

my little pony my little pony friendship is magic mlp mlp fim mlp g4 mlp fandom friendship is magic redemption arc mlp gen 4 chancellor neigh say mlp character

More Posts from Bat2pony and Others

bat2pony

8 months ago

Cartoon horbses!!!!! Do it!

Damn it I wanna watch the pony show again

@bat2pony this is your fault

Tags

my little pony mlp fim mlp g4 mlp fandom friendship is magic

6 notes View Post

bat2pony

8 months ago

YES I AGREE!!!

Honestly, I don’t understand the design choice at all. I mean, other toys being released from this time looked so cool! More fluid with a modern feel. These toys feel like they wanted to capture earlier MLP gens retro feel on something that was very much not. Don’t even get me started on the gen 5 toys.

My dream gen4 my little pony toy

The discourse has long since passed on this since MLP Gen 4 has been out for years, and now they have the g5 toys which are even worse, but anyways.

I think its a real shame they didn't make the g4 pony toys have like... any poses.

Lauren Faust has such a dynamic artstyle and I understand how it was hard to make into 3D but I refuse to believe this was the best they could do:

When theyre posed they have ugly little tube legs and no elbow. I think lauren fausts artstyle works with horses because she actually tool the time to look at horse anatomy and make it unique and stylized but these look so bad and not even very dynamic when they do do the poses but usually they dont do any poses at all.

Tags

my little pony mlp mlp fim mlp g4 mlp toys yes I also like the toys not just the shows some of the g4 toys aren’t totally horrible I guess

563 notes View Post

bat2pony

3 months ago

MLP EQG FORGOTTEN FRIENDSHIP RANT:

I just rewatched this special and JUST put together something.

Wallflower admits to using the stone to erase little memories at firsts, awkward hellos, saying the wrong thing, literally any public speaking, in her own words. SHE was the reason no one remembered her in the first place. She put herself out there when she got the courage, fumbled but didn’t follow through. Obviously this is suppose to teach us to be ourselves like every time but this feels loaded and a bit unrealistic if she was literally making ppl forget about her and then blaming them for not noticing her.

Tags

my little pony mlp equestria girls mlp equestria girls forgotten friendship wallflower mlp

7 notes View Post

bat2pony

8 months ago

"Is Discord okay? Perhaps someone should check on him." -Said no one in G5

Tags

mlp fim discord fluttercord screaming and crying this is breaking my heart

17K notes View Post

bat2pony

7 months ago

I WANT TO COLLECT MORE PONIES AND WATCH THROUGH ALL OF G1 CONTENT BUT IM STILL ON G4 AAAAAHHHHHHH

Tags

my little pony my little pony friendship is magic mlp mlp fim mlp g4 mlp fandom friendship is magic mlp gen 4 mlp g1 mlp gen 1

18 notes View Post

bat2pony

2 months ago

Flutterbat my beloved 💗🦇

flutterbat!

Tags

my little pony mlp mlp fim fluttershy bat pony flutterbat

49 notes View Post

bat2pony

9 months ago

Horbse 🐴

Tags

my little pony my little pony friendship is magic mlp fim mlp g4 mlp fandom equestria girls friendship is magic mlp gen 4 thisisthefunniestthingtohappeninFiM horse pony

11 notes View Post

bat2pony

7 months ago